Part 107 briefings

A drone fell into a parade crowd. The operator went to jail.

The FAA isn't the only authority that can charge a drone pilot. In Seattle, a city prosecutor won a reckless endangerment conviction after a drone hit two people at a parade.

Article 4 min read Part 107

At Seattle's 2015 Pride Parade, a drone operator lost control. The drone came down into the crowd, struck a woman in the head and hit a man. The woman suffered a concussion. Two years later, a jury convicted the operator of a crime.

In short

  • The charge came from the city, not the FAA. Seattle prosecuted the operator for reckless endangerment, a gross misdemeanor under city law.
  • A unanimous jury convicted. The sentence was 30 days in jail and a $500 fine.
  • The operator was a professional. By the city's account, the operator ran an aerial photography business.

What happened

According to the Seattle City Attorney's Office:

  • During the parade, the operator lost control of the drone.
  • It struck a woman in the head, causing a concussion, and hit a man, who had a minor bruise.
  • The drone came to rest near Safeco Plaza on 4th Avenue.
  • In January 2017 a six-person jury in Seattle Municipal Court unanimously convicted the operator of reckless endangerment. The charge carried up to 364 days in jail and a $5,000 fine.
  • In February 2017 the court sentenced the operator to 30 days in jail and a $500 fine. The city had asked for 90 days.

Two systems can come after you

Who What they enforce What they can do
The FAA Part 107 and federal aviation law Civil penalties of up to $75,000 per violation, and certificate suspension or revocation
State and local prosecutors Criminal laws such as reckless endangerment, assault or trespass Criminal charges, fines and jail
The people you hit Negligence, in civil court Lawsuits for medical costs and damages

Being legal under Part 107 doesn't protect you from the other two.

Flying near people today

This flight happened before Part 107 took effect in 2016. Today, flying over people is restricted under 14 CFR 107.39 and Subpart D, which limit which drones can fly over people and under what conditions. Flying over open-air crowds is the most restricted case of all.

  • Know your drone's category for operations over people before you take any job near a crowd.
  • Plan the flight path away from people, and plan where the drone goes if you lose control.
  • Write the plan down before the job. If something goes wrong, the plan is your record of the care you took.

A checklist wouldn't have saved this flight

A pre-flight checklist confirms the drone and the setup are ready. It doesn't ask whether the flight should happen at all. Over a packed parade route, the safe answer was not to fly.

  • Assess the risk before you commit: who is underneath, where the drone goes if you lose control, and what happens if it comes down.
  • Make a GO/NO-GO call and record it with the reason.
  • Be willing to call no-go. Turning down a shot costs one job. A drone in a crowd can cost the business, and here it cost the operator 30 days in jail.

How AYNA helps

  • A risk assessment and a GO/NO-GO call before you commit. Meridian, AYNA's mission-planning agent, helps you weigh a mission's risk (crew, aircraft, location, weather and airspace) and gives a clear GO/NO-GO call. You mark the risk assessment complete on the mission, and the final call stays with the pilot in command. Sometimes the right call is not to fly.
  • A record of every mission, with location and operation area, client, assigned pilots and aircraft, and planned and actual times.
  • A signed pre-flight checklist for every flight, time-stamped, so you can show what you checked before launch.
  • Every record in one place: certificates, recurrent training, aircraft registrations, Remote ID, waivers and flight records, checked against Part 107.
  • The business side too. AYNA One runs your storefront, bookings and Stripe payments, so the platform that keeps you ready also brings in the work.

Sources

  1. Seattle City Attorney, City Attorney's Office prevails in drone case (Jan 13, 2017)
  2. Seattle City Attorney, Drone operator sentenced to 30 days for reckless endangerment conviction (Feb 24, 2017)
  3. 14 CFR 107.39, Operation over human beings (eCFR)