Part 107 briefings

A drone hit a Black Hawk over Staten Island. The NTSB named the cause in one line.

Federal investigators found the pilot intentionally flew beyond visual line of sight and didn't fully know the rules. Here's what that means for every flight you make.

Article 4 min read Part 107

On the evening of September 21, 2017, a DJI Phantom 4 collided with a UH-60M Black Hawk helicopter about 300 feet over the water, a mile east of Midland Beach, Staten Island. The drone was destroyed and the helicopter was damaged. Nobody was hurt.

In short

  • The NTSB found the cause was the drone pilot's failure to see and avoid the helicopter "due to his intentional flight beyond visual line of sight."
  • It named a contributing factor: "the sUAS pilot's incomplete knowledge of the regulations and safe operating practices."
  • The lesson is two rules: keep the drone in sight, and give way to crewed aircraft.

What the NTSB found

Finding NTSB wording
Probable cause "the failure of the sUAS pilot to see and avoid the helicopter due to his intentional flight beyond visual line of sight"
Contributing factor "the sUAS pilot's incomplete knowledge of the regulations and safe operating practices"
Damage "The helicopter received minor damage, and the sUAS was destroyed."

The key word is intentional. This wasn't a flyaway. The drone was flown out of sight on purpose, so nobody at the controls could see the helicopter coming.

The rules behind it

Rule What it says
Visual line of sight (14 CFR 107.31) You or your visual observer must be able to see the drone throughout the flight, well enough to know where it is and to see and avoid other aircraft.
Right of way (14 CFR 107.37) Your drone must yield to all other aircraft and can't pass close enough to create a collision hazard.

The camera feed on your controller doesn't count as line of sight. It shows what's in front of the drone, not what's coming at it.

Keep it from being you

  • Keep the drone where you can see it with your own eyes, or use a visual observer who can.
  • Assume low-flying aircraft are nearby around shorelines, harbors, hospitals, highways and city edges. Helicopters work at drone altitudes.
  • If you hear or see an aircraft, descend and give way. Don't wait to see which way it turns.
  • Know the rules before the job, not after. The NTSB listed incomplete knowledge of the rules as a factor. Recurrent training exists for this.

How AYNA helps

  • A signed pre-flight checklist for every flight, time-stamped and tied to the mission, so you can show what you checked and when.
  • Recurrent training tracked for every pilot, with reminders before it comes due, alongside certificates, aircraft registrations, Remote ID and flight records, all checked against Part 107.
  • A GO/NO-GO call before you commit. Meridian, AYNA's mission-planning agent, helps you weigh a mission's risk (crew, aircraft, location, weather and airspace) and gives a clear GO/NO-GO call. You mark the risk assessment complete on the mission, and the final call stays with the pilot in command. Sometimes the right call is not to fly.
  • The business side too. AYNA One runs your storefront, bookings and Stripe payments, so the platform that keeps you ready also brings in the work.

Sources

  1. NTSB, Investigation DCA17IA202 (Sept 21, 2017, Staten Island, NY)
  2. 14 CFR 107.31, Visual line of sight aircraft operation (eCFR)
  3. 14 CFR 107.37, Operation near aircraft; right-of-way rules (eCFR)